MacBooks are high-value items, which means scammers put more effort into their schemes. But properly vetted deals can save you $500-1000 compared to Apple refurbished. Here’s how to buy with confidence.
Apple Silicon vs Intel: This is the big one
This single factor affects value more than anything else right now.
Apple Silicon (M1, M2, M3, M4):
- Dramatically faster, incredible battery life, runs cool and quiet
- Full support for current and future macOS
- Worth paying more for
Intel (2020 and earlier):
- Still functional for basic tasks
- May lose macOS support in coming years
- Significantly cheaper—can be solid value if you know the limitations
How to check: Apple menu (top left) → About This Mac → Chip
Shows “Intel Core i5/i7/i9”? It’s Intel. Shows “Apple M1/M2/M3/M4”? It’s Apple Silicon.
Our take: Unless you’re on a tight budget for basic tasks, go Apple Silicon. The performance and battery life difference is substantial.
The butterfly keyboard problem
MacBook Pro 2016-2019 and MacBook 12” used the “butterfly keyboard”—and it’s notorious for:
- Sticky or unresponsive keys
- Keys that repeat or don’t register
- Repairs costing $300-700
Test it thoroughly:
- Open TextEdit or Notes
- Type every key multiple times
- Pay special attention to spacebar, E, R, T keys (most common failures)
- Listen for any keys that sound different or feel sticky
If you’re buying a butterfly keyboard model, the price should reflect the risk. Or look for ones that had the keyboard replaced under Apple’s free program (ask for proof).
Battery health: Check the cycle count
MacBook batteries are rated for 1000 cycles before hitting 80% capacity.
How to check:
- Apple menu → About This Mac → More Info → System Report
- Click “Power” in the left sidebar
- Find “Cycle Count” under Battery Information
| Cycle Count | What it means |
|---|---|
| Under 100 | Excellent—basically new battery |
| 100-300 | Very good |
| 300-500 | Good—plenty of life left |
| 500-800 | Fair—budget for replacement in 1-2 years |
| 800-1000+ | Battery likely degraded, factor in $199 replacement |
Also check “Condition”—should say “Normal” not “Service Recommended.”
Verify the specs yourself
Sellers misrepresent specs constantly. Always verify in person.
Apple menu → About This Mac shows:
- Model year and name
- Chip (M1, M2, Intel i7, etc.)
- Memory (RAM)
- Startup disk (SSD size)
If the listing says “16GB RAM, 512GB SSD” but About This Mac shows 8GB/256GB, you’re being scammed. This happens more than you’d think.
Common misrepresentations we see:
- Listing storage as RAM (“16GB” when they mean storage)
- “MacBook Pro 2020” when it’s actually 2019
- “1TB” drive that’s actually 512GB + they’re including an external
Run Apple Diagnostics
This built-in tool checks for hardware issues. Takes 2-3 minutes.
How to run it:
- Shut down the MacBook
- Turn it on and immediately hold the D key
- Wait for diagnostics to complete
- Note any error codes
What the codes mean:
- ADP000: No issues found—good to go
- PPF/PPR codes: Power or battery issues
- VDC/VDH codes: Display problems
- NDC/NDD codes: Camera issues
Any error code means potential repair costs. Look up the specific code before deciding.
Display issues to watch for
Flexgate (2016-2018 Pro): The display cable wears out over time, causing:
- Bright spots at the bottom of the screen (“stage lighting”)
- Display flickering when opening/closing the lid
- Eventually, complete display failure
Open and close the laptop several times while watching the screen carefully.
Staingate (anti-reflective coating): The screen coating can wear off, leaving blotchy patches. Common on 2013-2018 models. It’s cosmetic but annoying if you’re picky.
Dead pixels: Open pure white and pure black images. Look for pixels that stay the wrong color.
Activation Lock
MacBooks with T2 chip (2018+) and all Apple Silicon Macs support Activation Lock.
Check it:
- System Settings → Apple ID
- If signed into someone else’s account, they need to sign out
- After signout: Erase All Content and Settings
- Verify no Activation Lock appears during setup
For older Macs: Check System Settings → Apple ID → iCloud → Find My Mac. If enabled, they need to disable it before selling.
What’s a fair price?
Early 2026 Marketplace prices for good condition:
| Model | Good Condition |
|---|---|
| MacBook Air 15” (M3) | $1100-1300 |
| MacBook Air 13” (M3) | $900-1050 |
| MacBook Air 13” (M2) | $700-850 |
| MacBook Air 13” (M1) | $550-700 |
| MacBook Pro 16” (M3 Pro) | $1800-2200 |
| MacBook Pro 14” (M3 Pro) | $1400-1700 |
| MacBook Pro 14” (M3) | $1200-1400 |
| MacBook Pro 14” (M1 Pro) | $1000-1200 |
| Intel MacBook Pro 16” | $600-900 |
| Intel MacBook Air | $300-500 |
Prices for base configs. Add $100-200 for RAM/storage upgrades.
The sweet spot: M1 MacBook Air. Still excellent performance in 2026, and prices have come down nicely.
Your meeting checklist
Bring:
- Your own charger (verify charging works)
- A USB-C device to test ports
- Headphones to test audio jack
- WiFi network to connect to (or hotspot)
Test:
- About This Mac matches the listing
- Battery cycle count
- Every keyboard key
- Trackpad (all areas respond, Force Touch works)
- Display (dead pixels, flexgate, coating wear)
- All ports
- Speakers and headphone jack
- WiFi connectivity
- Apple Diagnostics (no errors)
- Activation Lock is disabled
Analyzing a MacBook listing? Spottable AI for Chrome verifies pricing for the actual specs, flags suspicious sellers, and spots scam patterns—before you make the trip.
What to Look For
- Check battery cycle count (Apple menu → About This Mac → System Report → Power)
- Verify RAM and storage match the listing (About This Mac)
- Test all ports (USB-C, MagSafe, headphone jack)
- Run Apple Diagnostics (hold D on startup)
- Check for Activation Lock (System Settings → Apple ID)
- Test keyboard thoroughly (especially butterfly keyboard models)
- Check display for dead pixels, coating issues, and flexgate
Red Flags
- Won't let you check About This Mac
- Listing says '16GB RAM' but doesn't specify model year
- Price way below market for specs listed
- Keyboard has shiny/worn keys but claims 'like new'
- Won't run Apple Diagnostics or demos normal use
- Missing original charger (claims 'lost it')
Common Scams
- Specs don't match listing (less RAM, smaller SSD)
- Battery replaced with low-quality third-party
- Activation Lock enabled after sale
- Water damage hidden internally
- Stolen MacBooks that get remotely locked
- Older model sold as newer (2019 vs 2020)
Deal Hunting Tips
- M1 MacBook Air is the sweet spot for value—still excellent in 2026
- Base model Pros often sell for Air prices by uninformed sellers
- Look for corporate sellers—often well-maintained
- After WWDC announcements, previous models drop 15-20%
- Battery cycle count under 300 is excellent; under 500 is good
Skip the guesswork
Spottable's AI analyzes apple listings instantly—deal score, fraud detection, and market value comparison in one tap.
iOS app coming soon